Weight loss is all the rage now to achieve aesthetic and health goals, but we find ourselves wanting to use easy and quick approaches to get there. The hCG diet, a diet that pops up every few years with a resurgence of popularity. It promises rapid fast weight loss without experiencing hunger using calorie deficits and hormone injections; however, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) deems this diet illegal and dangerous.
In this blog post, we will outline what the hCG diet is, why it is not the weight loss best method, and what some alternative options are to help you accomplish your weight and body goals.
What Is the hCG Diet?
To understand the hCG diet, we first need to talk about hCG. What is it?
HCG - human chorionic gonadotropin - is a hormone produced by the placenta during early stages of pregnancy. It mainly stimulates progesterone, the pregnancy-maintaining hormone, to support growth of the fetus and preventing any complications from occurring; it has also been used to help treat fertility issues.
The weight-loss diet was first proposed in the 1950’s by English physician Albert Simeons, and it has two components:
Severe caloric restriction to between 500-800 calories per day
hCG hormone injections
Following these steps supposedly, per Dr. Simeons, allows participants to burn body fat, not muscle mass, without experiencing hunger. It will also regulate hormones and boost metabolism in the process.
The diet is also divided into 3 phases
Loading phase
Weight loss phase
Maintenance phase
During the loading phase, a participant will start the hCG injections while eating high fat, high calorie foods for 2 days. Then, they move on to the weight loss phase; hCG injections continue, but the calorie restriction to 500 calories begins. This routine continues for 3 to 6 weeks. Finally, during the maintenance phase, hCG is discontinued while participants gradually increase food intake, avoiding sugar and starches, for 3 weeks. After that, who knows what diet a previous participant may follow? Whatever it is, that weight will likely be regained, rendering the diet futile.
How Does the hCG Diet Contribute to Weight Loss?
It is important to note that weight and fat loss seen in individuals who follow this diet is not linked to hCG, and there is no proven relationship between hCG and weight. Rapid weight loss on this diet stems from the drastic caloric deficit alone.
A caloric deficit of less than half the recommended amount of calories per day is able to sustain basal metabolic needs, or baseline body and organ function, without contributing to further storage of fat. The body may think it’s starving, so it reduces the number of calories it burns in order to conserve energy. The energy it then chooses to burn is fat so that it can maintain and protect and protein and muscle mass.
In order to achieve this unrealistic energy restriction while still fueling the body with healthy nutrients, a participant would need calorie-free drinks, lean proteins and low-carbohydrate fruits and vegetables. Very low-calorie and very low-fat items squeezed into two meals per day. Simply put, this is not enough variety or food to lead a healthy lifestyle while promoting weight loss.
How True Are the Claims?
Simply put, there is no scientific evidence backing any of the proposed outcomes of this diet.
There has been minimal research conducted on this diet, but the research available suggests all we need it to: hCG and a placebo have the exact same effects on weight loss, metabolism and hormone regulation- sometimes, the placebo may have performed better. Also, there is no evidence supporting claims of the diet reducing hunger. The boosted metabolism claim is also untrue, as being hungry actually slows metabolism due to shifts in hunger and satiety hormones; furthermore, hCG does not play any sort of role in hunger cues and hunger-related hormones.
All of that being said, the claims of the diet on weight and fat loss is partly true, but it is not as a result of the hCG injections. As stated previously, any drastic weight loss seen is due to the severe dietary and calorie restrictions, but this weight loss is unsafe and unsustainable.
Is the hCG Diet Safe?
The simple answer is NO!
The FDA has not approved of this diet or the use of over-the-counter hCG drugs, which are common to use for this diet because physicians will not prescribe hCG to anyone who does not medically need it. Numerous mild side effects, such as headache, fatigue and depression, occur from the use of hCG.
But this diet can cause more severe side effects to occur, not limited to: irritability, depression, fluid buildup, and swelling of the breasts, blood clotting and vessel blockages, irregular heartbeats, nutrient deficiencies, gallstone formation, and more.
Is quick weight loss worth all of those extra (harmful) problems?
If safe and sustainable weight loss is something you are interested in, there are plenty of effective, science-backed methods to employ in place of this diet. Consult with a physician or dietitian about which approaches are right for you.
What’s A Good, Sustainable Weight Loss Plan Instead Of the hCG Diet?
The most crucial aspect of sustainable weight loss that is missing from the hCG diet is lifestyle modifications. By making small, gradual and feasible changes in diet, exercise and mindset, it will be easier to not only lose weight but also keep it off long-term.
A fundamental principle of weight loss is creating a small and gradual calorie deficit, which means consuming fewer calories than your body needs for maintenance; what the hCG diet got wrong was promoting a dangerous restriction, not a safe deficit. As the body has adapted to a minor calorie deficit, more calories can be eliminated over a steady period of time, and we are able to abide by those changes. By monitoring portion sizes and tracking energy intake, you can ensure that you're in a calorie deficit to support healthy weight loss.
Another effective strategy for weight loss is focusing on a balanced macronutrient distribution, which includes carbohydrates, protein and fat. All three macros are very important to optimizing the function of the body and maximizing health. Experimenting with different distributions, such as higher protein or moderate carbohydrate intake, can help optimize satiety, muscle preservation, and metabolic function. Consulting with a registered dietitian can provide personalized guidance in determining the ideal macronutrient ratios for your body and goals.
Mindful eating is also an important factor to incorporate into lifestyle to promote weight loss. Paying attention to hunger and fullness cues, listening to what your body wants and needs, savoring each bite, and eating with intention all play a role in maintaining healthy habits for life.
Exercise is also a healthy habit to develop for weight loss. The Physical Activity Guidelines for Americans recommends 150 minutes per week of moderate-intensity exercise and 2 days per week of strength training; however, the best way to adopt regular exercise and keep it in your routine is to do something enjoyable and practical for you.
How To Enhance Your Weight Loss Efforts
If you want to lose weight in a safe way, there are several strategies you can employ to enhance your results.
Control your portions.
Incorporate variety in every meal.
Add in nutrient-dense foods.
Eat mindfully.
Stay hydrated.
Engage in exercise.
Weight loss is trial and error; it is not a one-size-fits-all scenario, and results are not immediate like the hCG diet suggests. Progress, however, is inevitable and is a step in the right direction. Sustainable weight loss is a personalized process, and consulting with a registered dietitian can provide tailored guidance to determine the ideal approach to weight loss for your body and goals that lasts a lifetime.
For tailored, expert guidance to support your weight loss journey, work with our dietitian team! We will provide you everything you need to successfully and sustainably lose weight and your insurance may cover most of it!